HDFC ERGO Must Pay ₹10 Lakh for Dengue Treatment, Delhi Consumer Commission Rules

HDFC ERGO refused cashless treatment and then rejected a dengue patient's reimbursement claim, citing a two-year waiting period for a spinal condition. The Delhi State Commission found dengue was not in the exclusion clause.

By Samadhan Sarathi Editorial Team··5 min read
HDFC ERGO dengue waiting period ruling cover
Illustration (AI-generated)

Case at a glance

InsurerHDFC ERGO
Decided byDelhi State Commission
Amount ordered₹10 Lakh
Published16 Nov 2026

HDFC ERGO General Insurance refused cashless treatment and then rejected the reimbursement claim of a Delhi policyholder who was admitted with dengue, citing a two-year waiting period for a spinal condition. On 6 October 2026 the Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission dismissed the insurer’s appeal and let the District Commission’s order stand.

Two hospitals, two refusals

On 2 November 2019 a Delhi policyholder had a high fever. After consulting a doctor he was diagnosed with dengue and, on the doctor’s advice, was hospitalised at a private hospital in East Delhi on 3 November 2019. On his request for cashless treatment a surveyor visited the hospital and recorded a statement from his wife. On 6 November 2019 the insurer declined the cashless request, and he paid ₹3,71,225 to the hospital against the bill dated 11 November 2019.

Not satisfied with the treatment, he asked to be shifted to another private hospital and was admitted there the same day. His cashless request was declined again on 12 November 2019, on what he called false and baseless grounds. He was discharged on 21 November 2019. By his account he paid a total bill of ₹8,11,236 at the second hospital by taking loans and disposing of his wife’s jewellery. His total claim, with pre- and post-hospitalisation expenses of ₹6,16,962, came to ₹17,99,423.

A claim rejected for a spine problem

On 7 December 2020 the insurer rejected the reimbursement claim by email. As recorded in the order, the stated reason was a prolapsed intervertebral disc (PIVD), which the insurer said fell under a two-year waiting period between the two policies he held. The policyholder filed the complaint on 16 December 2020. He held a “Health Suraksha Policy, Silver Plan” that had been renewed from 2011, with sums insured rising from ₹3 lakh to ₹10 lakh.

Before the District Commission

The insurer filed a written statement but did not lead evidence. It was proceeded against ex parte on 13 October 2022, and its application to set that aside was dismissed on 11 January 2023. On 31 October 2023 the District Commission observed that all the policies on record were single-page policies with no terms and conditions annexed, and that the insurer had not shown the terms were given to the policyholder. It relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Bharat Watch Company v. National Insurance.

The claim was for ₹17.99 lakh, but the sum insured was ₹10 lakh. The policyholder argued that his treatment ran across two policy years. The District Commission held that the treatment began and ended within the 2018-19 policy year and limited the claim to ₹10 lakh, with interest at 6% a year from 16 December 2020, ₹30,000 as compensation and ₹20,000 as costs, and 9% interest if the ₹10.5 lakh total was not paid within 30 days. His counsel accepted the ₹10 lakh limit during arguments.

The appeal: what the Commission read

HDFC ERGO appealed on 27 March 2024 (First Appeal No. 219 of 2024). Its case was that the exclusion clause was part of the policy schedule given to the insured, that the terms and conditions had been provided, that the burden of proving they were not received lay on the policyholder, and that he was admitted for a fall diagnosed as PIVD, which falls under the two-year waiting period. The policyholder replied that the appeal was barred by limitation, that the terms were never supplied to him, and that cancelling the cashless facility was deficiency in service.

The Commission, with Justice Sangita Dhingra Sehgal as President and Ms Bimla Kumari as Member, turned to Clause A(ii) of Section V, the special terms and conditions, which provides a “waiting period of 24 months from the first policy commencement date” for the illnesses, diagnoses and procedures in a table. That table covers ENT, gynaecological, orthopaedic (including prolapsed intervertebral disc), gastrointestinal, urogenital and eye conditions, among others. It then looked at the diagnosis dated 2 November 2019, which clearly stated that the policyholder was suffering from dengue fever.

The finding

does not apply to the illness of the Respondent

The Commission held that dengue fever is not present in the exclusion clause, so the 24-month waiting period “does not apply to the illness of the Respondent”. Even after careful analysis of the terms and conditions the insurer said were provided, it found no “cogent reason for cancellation of the cashless facility”. The appeal was dismissed on 6 October 2026, nearly six years after the complaint was filed.

Samadhan Sarathi

If you are facing a similar rejection, a clear first letter to the insurer matters. The Letter Kit from Samadhan Sarathi drafts it for you and you file it yourself. If you want the whole matter handled, that is Bima Samadhan.

Our guides: claim rejected, grievance letter, escalation letter, Insurance Ombudsman complaint.

Samadhan Sarathi is a private service. It is not the insurer, IRDAI or the Ombudsman. Every case depends on its own facts.

FAQ

Which court decided this case?

The Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, in First Appeal No. 219 of 2024, on 6 October 2026.

What was the insurer’s reason for rejecting the claim?

A two-year waiting period for a prolapsed intervertebral disc (PIVD), as recorded in the order.

What did the Commission find about dengue?

That dengue fever is not in the exclusion clause, so the 24-month waiting period did not apply to it.

Source: Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, First Appeal No. 219 of 2024, decided 6 October 2026. Read from the judgment text in our legal library on 16-Nov-2026.

Last updated: 16 November 2026

Legal Disclaimer

Claim rejected for a similar reason?Tell us what happened. We review it and explain your options.
Start my case
Know someone facing this?

Send them this story. It may help with their claim.

Discussion

Comments

Comments are checked before they appear.
No comments yet. Share your experience or ask a question about this story.

Please don't post policy numbers, claim numbers, phone numbers or medical reports here. For help with your own claim, use Start my case. Comments are general discussion, not advice. See our privacy policy.